The last time I saw my mother was the day I finished my junior year of high school. It’s been more than 40 years since I basked in the warmth of her smile, or heard her musical laugh. And even longer since we argued, but I still remember the last time she annoyed me.
She had neglected to compliment me on my newly acquired driving skills. “Aren’t you going to say anything?” I asked before tossing the car keys towards her. They hit her thin shoulder and fell to the garage floor. She looked at me, startled, her blue eyes filled with hurt.
She was dying and that made me mad. For the rest of that spring, I put my new driver’s license to good use, shuttling back and forth between home and the hospital every day after school.
She’s missed a lot. She wasn’t there for my high school and college graduations… or my wedding. She never met my husband or her two grandsons. And yet, after all this time, our relationship lives on.
Since her death, my mother has been with me many times — especially when I do things that she couldn’t. The first time I traveled to Europe with a friend, she was there too. She had always wanted to go, but because of my travel-phobic father, she never had the chance. On that first trip, I lit candles in churches all over England for my Jewish mother.
She made it clear that I was going to college. Trapped in a difficult marriage, a college degree, more than anything else, symbolized freedom to her. She badly wanted the ability to support herself, and she didn’t want me to be stuck, dependent —like her.
Each time that I checked a new accomplishment off her list —earning that diploma, landing my first “real” job, and renting my own apartment — I could almost hear her cheering in the distance.
Because she made sure that I got the extras, like music lessons and summer camps, my sons got them too, even when the cost seemed onerous. She’d be thrilled to know that one grandson recently performed at the Kennedy Center, and that the other is living and working abroad. She may be gone, but her influence still has legs.
Shortly before my 16th birthday, on a sunny, brisk spring day, she took me to a nearby shopping center to pick out a bracelet. We left the store with a one-inch sterling silver cuff that came in a maroon flannel bag. In my mind’s eye I see us talking and laughing companionably as we stroll from store to store.
I think of us together every time I wear that bracelet. The memory of that ordinary day—so long ago that it now seems extraordinary—reminds me to treasure every small moment I can snatch with my husband and sons.
She and I didn’t have a lot of tough conversations. I was rarely in trouble, but because she was my safe place, my comfort zone, I knew it was important to provide that space for my own children. I think, I hope, they know that they can tell me anything.
Often, I imagine her in the kitchen, cooking a meal with my younger son, who shares more than a passing resemblance to her father in both looks and spirit. Or joking with my older son, who always has a good story to tell, and whose big, blue eyes match hers. When I do those things, she’s there too
If she were still alive, my mother would be 92 this month. Even though she has been absent for most of my life, memories of what she said and did guided me through early adulthood, marriage, and motherhood. I am now seven years older than she was when she died. As I move through middle age and progress toward old age, she can no longer show me the way.
And yet, as long as I am alive, and still straining to remember her voice, and hear her laugh, the relationship goes on.
***
This post is part of a series about mother-daughter relationships published on “Daily Plate of Crazy.” Click here to read other posts in the series.
Beautiful.
Thanks Laura. You have no idea how much it means to me to have both your mother and father in my life. Aside from the few people left who knew me as a child, they also knew my mother. Not too many people in my life these days did.
So beautiful, Judith. You brought a tear to my eye.
Each day and each conversation are so precious.
When life gets busy, we take so much for granted, but we shouldn’t. We should treasure each moment – even the “bad” ones.
It’s so heartwarming to know that you carry your mother’s spirit with you on your journey. The people who love us best have a way of staying around no matter what.
Jamie,
Thanks for stopping by. Yes those special people do have a way of staying around.
Judith,
This is one of the most beautiful pieces of work I have ever read. I could go line by line, but suffice it to say you words mean so much to me. I hope as Alexandra and Graham go through their lives, they feel their dad in a similar way. Thank you for opening your heart.
Thank you Cheryl,
I hope they do too.
This is such a gorgeous piece of writing, and so deeply felt. Thank you so much for sharing it with my readers.
Thank you “Wolf.” If you hadn’t invited me, I never would have written this! I’m glad that it touched so many people.
So sad to lose someone like that when you were so young. A beautiful post. I respond to many lines — like “I lit candles in churches all over England for my Jewish mother.”
Judith, this is beautiful truth told I opened it a few days ago, saw the photo of your mom and did not want to read it. In a few days it will be the 4 anniversary of my moms death and a week after that my dads. Christmas just doesn’t have the same meaning for me any more. its feels more like a chore I have to hold my breath and just get through to the other side.
But what you wrote is beautiful. And I am reminded of the wonderful time we shared and that she did get to see my accomplishments and that of her grandchildren and great grandchildren.
Life is a blessing. Thank you.
love Kathleen
You know I’d give my right arm to have met your mom, right? I’m glad that she did get to share your accomplishments and your two amazing boys. xo
Thank you, Judith, this is a very special gift. I had no idea what you were going through during high school and wish I could have been more of a friend then. I faced similar loss four years later when my father passed away when I was a junior in college. I, too, was mad at him (at his illness, really, but it took me years to figure that out) although at the time I didn’t feel I would ever admit that to anyone. And likewise, he had made it clear that college was the way to open up many options for the future.
I missed him terribly the day I got married and deeply regret that he did not ever meet my husband and children. But like you, I concentrate on the happy memories and share the gifts of compassion, humor, and patience that he gave to me. Blessings to you and your family. It sounds like you have carried her spirit on!
Hi Carol,
Thank you for stopping by. Even as the time passes and the immediate pain subsides a bit, it is still hard to lose a parent at any stage of life. Imagining that she might be watching helps keep her alive for me.
How beautifully written Judith.. and what a wonderful tribute to your mother… I am sure she would be immensely proud of the woman you have become… Have a wonderful holiday and very happy new Year… xv
Thank you Vicki, Happy Holidays to you as well!
So beautiful, I am absolutely speechless. Just deeply moved.
Namaste.
H
What a beautiful piece of writing! So brave and revealing. It was quite moving..
Deborah from Melbourne
Found you through Lost in Arles. Beautiful writing. I miss my own mother every single day and always will. My heart was crushed when she died and her passing left a hole in my life that will never be filled – and that’s OK for me to live in that knowledge. Your mother will be your ‘safe place’ forever. We’re the lucky daughters.
Anna,
I am so glad you stopped by! Yes, loss is something we learn to live with and is part of accepting the good and bad that comes with the glory of living. I recently came across these lines by Rilke: “Let everything happen to you: beauty and terror. Just keep going. No feeling is final.”